OK, today I bought a box of Pampers Overnights size 7. Meijer had the Pampers Swaddlers size 8 as well, but as these seemed a little thicker and have been stated by multiple people to have the same dimensions as Swaddlers 8, I bought them. I wish I'd bought the Tippy Toes instead. I'll use these, and so far I've only used a few of them, but here's my review so far.
What I like: These are very comfortable, and seem to be good quality. There seems to be a wicking pad over the top of the fluff which adds some structure, and might reduce bunching and clumping. I'm happy with the absorbency, and haven't messed them, but the "poop pocket" and structure seem promising that these will handle whatever I serve them (within reason, of course.) They MAY be a little more absorbent than the Tippy Toes, but I'll test that later. I don't think there's a big difference. These remind me a lot of the Rascal and Friends size 7s.
What I DON'T like: These are not as stretchy as the Tippy Toes size 7, and the wings are not as well attached to the front of the diaper. Like the Gentle Steps/Kidgets, the wings will tear out of the diaper if you try to make them hold the tapes with significant tension on them. The tabs do stretch, but not as much as the GS/K/TT do, and as a result of the lower stretch and necessity of reaching the landing zone, I have to use 2 extra tabs to make them reach. For comparison, the GS/K will reach with 1 extra tab, and the TT doesn't need any help at all because of the usable width of the wings. Also, what
IS that scent? Aside from the fact that if I wear these in public I'll have to be very generous with cologne to cover it, I find it unpleasant. The Luvz smelled cute......these smell.........somehow off-putting in a way I'm struggling to describe. There's cute baby overtones, with undertones of something sour, and slightly digested. It's not quite to gag level, but to me, it's bad.
For me, the scent, the sizing, and the fact that for the money I could have had twice as many of the Tippy Toes size 7s means that I won't be buying these again. I see why
@PampersCowboy switched, but now I've tried them and no longer have to wonder. I'd get Rascal and Friends sooner than these, but next box will probably be Tippy Toes.