- Messages
- 774
- Role
- Other
carol said:I don't know who you mean, but I've done that exact test for myself, to determine which diaper for nighttime I'd order from then on. I tested Northshore Supreme, 24/7, BetterDry/Crinklz, Wellness, and Abena -- the first three were all in the top tier. Sorry Adam, but NS Supreme did not exceed 24/7 nor BetterDry. Furthermore, in actual usage at night, the Supremes leaked out the back sometimes. The winner in both testing and everyday usage was BetterDry.
Adam,
No other independent review that I've seen has put NS Supreme ahead of all else. I'd be interested if you could find one. And I've tested/reviewed myself as I said. You really ought to include some other diapers in your top-tier "5 drop" rating -- that's all. Even *if* Supreme were slightly better, others deserve to share the same top-tier.
I'm not the only one who sees it that way.
Ok no problem. I can understand your view. We'll have them all retested. Unfortunately, quantities and positions are never identical in "actual use" so those results are anecdotal but can't be repeated. There's lots of ways to test diapers that would produce different results from test to test. We'll certainly be re-evaluating the absorbency scales more as more newer diapers are introduced.