I personally haven't tried tykables but can say XL Rears Alpaca worked better than Abena but they also cost alot more. I have in past used the L4 Plastic Backed as my go to diapers and mainly use Rearz inspire+ for special use(still use Rearz for.special use). But if your also wondering about size again I haven't used tykable as XL is sort of new to them but for me I have always had to size up in abdl diapers and had no issues.