Rating of ATNs vs. other non-printed diapers.

What do you rate ATNs versus other non-printed diapers?

  • 1

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 2

    Votes: 3 37.5%
  • 3

    Votes: 3 37.5%
  • 4

    Votes: 2 25.0%
  • 5

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    8
  • This poll will close: .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Musashi

Banned
Messages
85
Role
Private
I was curious what's the general rating of these since I wear them 24/7.

I really like them- Mostly for the overly-tape-tight ness (but sometimes leak because I drank a lot of liquid/forget to change/blah.)


Please rate 1-5 versus other non-printed diapers.
Thanks :D
 

Trevor

Est. Contributor
Messages
8,724
Role
Adult Baby, Diaper Lover, Babyfur
I'm rating these on the Trevor scale, which is Trevor's evaluation of how well they do what they are designed to do, coupled with how much I enjoy wearing them.

Attends with Waistband: 1
Depends Protection with Tabs: 1
Secure Plus: 1
Unique Wellness Briefs: 2
Unique Wellness Superio: 2
Tranquility ATN: 3
Abena Abri-Form Classic Lvl 4: 3
Confidry 24/7: 3
Tena Slip Active Fit Maxi: 4
ABU Simple Ultra: 4
Secure X-Plus: 4
Bambino Bianco: 4
Betterdry Briefs: 4
Rearz Inspire: 4
ABU Simple: 5
Northshore Supreme Lite: 5
Northshore Supreme: 5

In a few cases, like Simple, Simple Ultra, and Betterdry, I've only worn the printed versions but they are described as the same diaper without the print, so I think I can grade them as well. Anything rated 3 or better, I'd happily pay for at the prices I've typically seen them. Lower, and I'd need a sale or particular conditions under which I might consider them okay. I didn't include diapers that are no longer in production.
 

Musashi

Banned
Messages
85
Role
Private
I'm rating these on the Trevor scale, which is Trevor's evaluation of how well they do what they are designed to do, coupled with how much I enjoy wearing them.

Attends with Waistband: 1
Depends Protection with Tabs: 1
Secure Plus: 1
Unique Wellness Briefs: 2
Unique Wellness Superio: 2
Tranquility ATN: 3
Abena Abri-Form Classic Lvl 4: 3
Confidry 24/7: 3
Tena Slip Active Fit Maxi: 4
ABU Simple Ultra: 4
Secure X-Plus: 4
Bambino Bianco: 4
Betterdry Briefs: 4
Rearz Inspire: 4
ABU Simple: 5
Northshore Supreme Lite: 5
Northshore Supreme: 5

In a few cases, like Simple, Simple Ultra, and Betterdry, I've only worn the printed versions but they are described as the same diaper without the print, so I think I can grade them as well. Anything rated 3 or better, I'd happily pay for at the prices I've typically seen them. Lower, and I'd need a sale or particular conditions under which I might consider them okay. I didn't include diapers that are no longer in production.
Thanks :)
 

ieyasu

Est. Contributor
Messages
75
Role
Adult Baby, Diaper Lover
It's been a long while since I tried the ATNs but they weren't much better than a Depend Maximum Brief.

The Northshore Supreme and the Betterdry are in a totally different league. I like both of these but currently prefer Betterdry to the Supremes.

My scale is similar to Trevor but personal for makes a big difference!

1 STORE BRAND
2 Depend / ATN
3 Confidry 24/7
4 Bambino Blanco
5 Northshore Sumpreme & Better dry Briefs

Note: I'm a large.


-Ieyasu
 

Llayden

Est. Contributor
Messages
881
Role
Diaper Lover, Incontinent
I'm not sure which direction your scale is supposed to go, so I will just tell you what I think about ATN's. I think they're pretty bad. They look, feel, sound, and nearly perform as well as a large pad glued to a plastic bag. They have ridiculous amounts of excess plastic, the padding is extremely asymmetrical in its distribution, and they fall apart quickly. However, it has been a few years since I tried them last. From memory, I'd rank them on par with plastic backed Depends.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top