goodnites boxers vs briefs

[Slycamer]

my review though i have not tried boxer style

briefs​

they are thin but hold 1-2 wettings
flooding leaks a little.
the waist/legbands are alot stronger than underjams and can last through alot of movment.
cool designs

boxers​

no designs.
sample fabric is really soft in stores
the diaper section is plastic coated
more like descretion i guess you coould say.


Does anybody else want to share reviews/ facts.

 

[RubixFox]

Hmm well I can't state a fact on any of them since I haven't tried either one. I have tried goodnights, and they're just for looks mostly. Now I can say that from other reviews I've gotten, the boxers are a lot better than the underjam. I'm gonna sample them both myself, and find out which is better in my opinion.


~Rubix

 

[Wegs]

I'm planning on buying by the end of the month. I was planning on getting breifs anyway, I could always get boxers too.
*Counts money and is terrified of decreasing reserves, but is reassured in knowing I will be getting more at the end of the month*

 

[ZombifiedKitty]

The boxers are very flimsy and run very small, unlike the briefs which can stretch a lot more. Also the boxers have looser leg cuffs coupled with the fact that the gel in goodnites doesn't absorb fast the boxers tend to leak more. I do like goodnites briefs mainly cuz they are far more durable than underjams and the GN briefs are so fricken comfy too. I really treat them as an underwear substitute/ training pants for teens kinda thing. None of these really compare to a good quality diaper like a Molicare or better yet thick cloth.

 

[Dan09]

I've worn the new briefs and tried on of the boxers on when they were really new. Honestly I kinda liked the boxers more comfort-wise, although I didnt use either of them it seems like the boxers would hold more simply cuz they are bigger.

 

[Boyhood]

I've heard that the boxers are smaller. For whoever can normally fit into the briefs, the boxers are harder to get into because they don't stretch as far. I personally have only used a package of the goodnites briefs. Good if used slowly.

 

[WhiteWolf]

I have tried three of the goodnites varients: The soccer goodnites, the old waistband goodnites and the new waistband goodnites. I belive that the newer goodnites w/ waistband are not as good as the one prior (the "Catching Air" one) also considering that you got 1 less in the new package, but are still paying the same. I have never tried the goodnite boxers, if anyone could tell me if i had a chance to fit in them (25-26" waist, 27" hips; 110lbs) I would be glad to give a review/comparison on them.

I will edit this, if i try the boxers.

Underpants: Pro
-Good Designs (Personally do not like the fake fly)
-Decent Absorbancy. Holds 1 wetting well, maybe a small second wetting
-Sides hold
-Dosent clump up to much
-Discreet

Underpants Con:
-Cloth outer fabric peels off over time
-Not very thick

 

[Asher]

I haven't tried Goodnites in a long time. However, from what I remember, the briefs are pretty decent actually. They did leak however, which is why I stopped using them.

I have heard the the Boxers are better, but do not stretch as well. I have never used them, so I am not totally sure.

- Asher

 

[Cosmos]

In my experience, I've only tried the breif style. Honestly, they hold less than the baby diapers I use now. And although they fit better, they leaked after one wetting. I thought they kinda smelled like a hospital, too.

 

[MistuhFox]

Def like the breifs over the boxers myself.
Personal experiance: I've tried both, SOOO i can honestly say that the briefs stretch FAR more, i have a 34 inch waist (winter podge , working on that) and no problem wearing the briefs all day, but last summer, when my waist was a full 2 inches less (amazing what 15 pounds will do >_>) i still had problems slipping into the boxers, even hadda couple rip on me. But if you can fit in them they are comparable in comfort and absorbancy (IMO), so if you like the style better and can fit in them, all the power to you.

 

[trevorboy69]

boxers hold more and SWELL more. If you feel youre too smal for them, cut away the boxer material and weat the boxer liek a thing. Briefs are good as well..depends on what you want. I'd try one first..prob. boxers as there are less per package if ou dont like them.

 

[MistuhFox]

no i meant the WASTEBAND broke lol, my thighs can fit in them (barely) but its my damn waist thats the problem

 

[NoobSauce]

I'm not sure how to put this, so I'll say it directly:
The cloth on the boxers, when torn, tends to resemble a skirt.

 

[DotDotDot]

Doesn't everyone wear skirts under their pajamas?

 

[Slycamer]

i wen to the store today and they were gone. along with the new pakaging is already there ecept there is some old packaged ones. and the diaper amount is the same. i think they are triing to get rid of them since there isn;t any gils ones there either. but the boys section has morer than trippled in size.

 

[CrazyCanuck]

Boxers suck as compared to the briefs IMO. I managed to tear them every time I put em on. Briefs are for sure more durable and comfortable.

Kevin

 

[Gil]

Boxers never have been better than briefs, whether it's in diaper form or not. :biggrin:

 

[goodnitesgirl]

The boxer style is smaller the only thing I like about them is the diaper part is plastic rather than cloth like. Biggest con now is they are only releasing the boxers in the boy version the girl version has been discontinued probably because girls are less likely to wear the boxer style and boy bedwetters outnumber girls

 

[EvaIlyxtra]

IMO, I have only tried the briefs version and I would never try the boxers just because the briefs are just what diapers are all about. Are there any baby sized boxer style diapers? Briefs are just better. I wear boxer briefs regularly and boxers as underwear but I will always wear briefs as a diaper. Maybe try the girls version when I'm running low on the boys ones.

 

[barkd74]

I have tried every style of Goodnite since they came out and have to the the ones that said "trusted protection" were the best ever. Even though I'm just over the weight limit of the boxer style I love the plastic diaper under neath and they seem to hold more. Just wish they were a tad bigger so they would sit at my waist and not hips. I tear the crotch part of the boxer part so they fit a little better.