• Please go to your preferences page and make sure your "See Mature Topics" setting is set. Setting it to "Yes" means you see the Mature Topics forum (contains political and religious debates). Setting it to "No" means you do not see those threads.

"Cloth-like" disposables

Status
Not open for further replies.

Crinkly

Est. Contributor
Messages
114
Role
Diaper Lover
In my view, it's unfortunate that these have been displacing the traditional plastic backed diapers. The whole idea of the cloth-like outer covering breathing better seems such a myth.

First, they still have a layer of plastic behind the papery cloth-like outer covering. This makes sense though, as there would have to be something to stop pee from escaping. So I think the purpose of the cloth-like covering is to reduce noise and to allow a thinner sheet of plastic to be used, where the outer covering helps to protect it from being torn.

Otherwise, I don't see many functional advantages, but several drawbacks. One is that the outer covering tends to wick moisture where it's not wanted, even when the diaper has more capacity to use. The velcro-like fasteners tend to get full of fiber strands from the outer covering, and eventually don't hold as well. So, they're not really as refastenable as claimed. And some of these brands still use tapes, which are a poorer choice because they aren't that refastenable, even with the split taping system widely used among the European designs. A well designed plastic-backed diaper with quality tapes holds much better, and can be refastened many times.

I've tried the Attends Extended Wear and the Abena AirPlus, both of which had at least one of the aforementioned issues, and didn't breathe any better, because that inner plastic still tends to trap heat compared to regular underwear. So, I think the breatheability is more of a perception than a reality. Even in the summer time, if I'm going be in a disposable diaper, I'd rather have the real thing.

I don't even mind the sensation most of the time, as I'm used to it, and regard it as part of the fun experience of wearing diapers. The cloth-backed diapers do have their place, as they are good for stealth wearing. If I had to wear diapers for real, I'd probably have both types for flexibility but would lean toward the plastic ones most of the time. I sure hope a few good ones will always be around.
 

ade

Est. Contributor
Messages
3,818
Role
Other
the breatheability is just a load of rubbish; what the outer layer actually does is prevent sticking to the skin on the inner thigh, as a standard plastic outer does. and considering the increased absorbancy of these higer spec diapers, the fastening system is wholly inadequate to cope with the weight thereby requiring the wearing of a supportive garment. even on toddlers this sytem doesn't work and they end up toddling about with their underwear hanging off their arses like pot-bellied, scruffy drunkards.
 

Arlo

Est. Contributor
Messages
27
Role
Adult Baby, Diaper Lover
As much as I feel the cloth backed ones are less enjoyable, they are easier to refasten then most of the plastic backed varieties. Sometimes I am only able to wear and not use the diaper so it is nice to be able to put it back on.
 

JustInCase

Est. Contributor
Messages
115
Role
Diaper Lover
Makes you wonder if the corporate-heads actually do any product testing themselves. :detective3
If they did their companies would manufacture much higher quality diapers.

I have to agree that plastic is better, especially in high end diapers with lots of absorbancy since it provides better containment. When ever I wear in public I always use a cloth like diaper because they are always quieter, even when you wear tight underwear.
 

hen

Messages
68
Role
Diaper Lover, Other
I agree, when I went shopping, i could not find any ones that are plastic backed
 
D

Deleted member 221

Guest
i actually like the cloth backed ones better,as they where readily available when i went to buy some - so I'm used to them - so i'd rather have cloth backed diapers. but if i find that special girl who accepts my special TB gift, than she could treat me like a baby with plastic backing.

honestly guys i don't see the difference as as having plastic backed diapers have no difference in performance (from my view), and the plastic backed ones ar not more babyish,as most babies these days are wearing - cloth backed - disposables..

so the plastic backed ones really arn't more babyish at all,but if your thaught differ, than suit yourself.
 
Messages
591
Role
Diaper Lover, Babyfur, Diaperfur
I wore plastic-backed disposables when I was little, but I can't remember them very well.

All I've tried recently is cloth-backed, which I'm fine with except for one thing.
They tend to "sweat". I don't know if plastic-backed diapers do this, but I would think if they would they would to a much lesser degree, since the plastic is stronger.
 

Darkfinn

Banned
Messages
3,676
Role
Diaper Lover, Incontinent,
I have tried a few cloth-backed disposables... I find that with them I can't get nearly as snug of a fit as I can with plastic ones. The real tapes just seem to hold better than velcro knockoffs.
 

LuvsGurl

Est. Contributor
Messages
500
Role
Diaper Lover, Other
I have tried a few cloth-backed disposables... I find that with them I can't get nearly as snug of a fit as I can with plastic ones. The real tapes just seem to hold better than velcro knockoffs.
Well in am on the other side of the fence then my wetter half here. I love the Cloth likes for day time use. No they are not ideal for night time, but when I am going out with people or just to work Cloth-like is a great plus. I know Guys do not have to worry about it as much but those of us that are girls have to wear close fitting clothing, Cloth-likes are trimmmer, and less knoted. They also are more easly mistaked for underwear and have less sound.
 

Spiro910

Est. Contributor
Messages
381
Role
Diaper Lover, Babyfur
I wish I could find a good plastic-backed diaper here in Mexico :/ The nicest diaper we have is Tena Slip and it's cloth-backed and I have had a problem with diaper sweat :s
 

Possibly Insane

Est. Contributor
Messages
435
Role
Diaper Lover
The answer is simple: modern diapers are cheaper to make. That's it. Then, they rebrand them so it looks like it's healthier for your baby, and better for the earth. Bollocks.
 

Crinkly

Est. Contributor
Messages
114
Role
Diaper Lover
I wish I could find a good plastic-backed diaper here in Mexico :/ The nicest diaper we have is Tena Slip and it's cloth-backed and I have had a problem with diaper sweat :s
I recently tried a diaper brand made in Mexico - have you heard of Senior? It is plastic covered and has a nice crinkling sound to it, but not over the top. I found it to be not too bad for the money. Although it's rather thin and doesn't have elastic at the waist, which I prefer, it absorbs a lot more than it would first seem; about three good wettings.
 

Spiro910

Est. Contributor
Messages
381
Role
Diaper Lover, Babyfur
I recently tried a diaper brand made in Mexico - have you heard of Senior? It is plastic covered and has a nice crinkling sound to it, but not over the top. I found it to be not too bad for the money. Although it's rather thin and doesn't have elastic at the waist, which I prefer, it absorbs a lot more than it would first seem; about three good wettings.
I think I've seen it (not sure :/). I'll get a pack next time I am on a run for them :p Ty for the advice.
 
Messages
520
Role
Adult Baby, Diaper Lover, Incontinent
Diaper companies started making cloth-like backed diapers to reduce the amount of plastic they were using in diapers.
It's a business decision, as the price of oil increased so did the price of plastic.
It makes good business sense to reduce the amount of expensive materials in your products to remain competitive.
Since most sales are to people who need rather than like, diapers that are less like diapers will enjoy success.
Diapers that are plastic backed will always be around, as there will always be a niche market for products that have long lasting capabilities, they will just be more expensive.
 
Messages
338
Role
Diaper Lover, Sissy, Incontinent
First off: Diapers are suppose to crinkle!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Okay I got that off... :D:p.

And I just got to say to the post to kevindca post, that I sure hope plastic back diapers will ALWAYS be around... I been scared when everyone started to turn over to cloth. Yuck. I am glad you feel this way kevindca and I think you are right for what you said.

diaperedwolfcub
 

babybobby

Est. Contributor
Messages
593
Role
Adult Baby, Diaper Lover
I miss plastic backed diapers - cloth ones do not compare for me. I love being able to run my fingers over a smooth, warm, squishy surface - not some sweaty "cloth like" bollocks
 
Messages
338
Role
Diaper Lover, Sissy, Incontinent
OH! Something just came to me!!!! Alright as it was posted above... companies are starting to use cloth because it is cheaper. Well this is true... but also it goes for people who want to be discreet and need.

So what do the companies do? They make the diapers with cloth, and sell them at a cost more expensive than their plastic ones of the same brand and type. lol.

Them companies! They create a cheaper product... and sell it for more...

diaperedwolfcub
 

Crinkly

Est. Contributor
Messages
114
Role
Diaper Lover
But they're not cloth - they're cloth-like paper with plastic beneath.
 
D

Deleted member 221

Guest
Makes you wonder if the corporate-heads actually do any product testing themselves. :detective3
probably not, i wouldn't want a corporate oersone coming to my house (if i get one) and asking if they can test a product on my child.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top