I mostly wear pin-on cloth diapers, but my preferences are all over the place. I enjoy training pants (cloth and disposable), as well as AIO-type cloth and tape/tab disposables. In the disposable realm, I vastly prefer clothlike backing, hook-and-loop closures, and lots of elastic, and am one of those who frequently expresses a wish for adult-sized modern Pampers.
All that said, I definitely cannot call myself "not picky." Medical-looking diapers are out, and while I'll settle for plain white when I'm wearing cloth diapers, I strongly prefer baby prints on my disposables. I grudgingly accept adhesive tapes when other criteria are met, but if there are two adhesive tapes per side, that throws things into a "retro adult" category in my mind, which just doesn't work for me at all.