A few notes on Huggies Pull Ups vs Pampers Easy Ups...
On Easy Ups...
First off, Easy Ups don't have the wetness indicator. That's a bad sign right there.
Secondly, the "easy tear sides" on Easy Ups are anything but easy.
On Pull Ups...
The wetness indicator is pretty much useless to a child. It isn't enough to notice visually, and if I were a toddler I wouldn't really care.
The easy open sides work fantastic, and are refastenable. However, with those, doesn't that just make them a regular diaper?
The Big Difference:
The big difference is in the materials. Easy Ups actually feel like underwear. Pull Ups just don't.
Essentially, I don't see much difference between Pull Ups and slip on diapers - because that is what Pull Ups are: a diaper.
So, as an ABDL, I love the Pull Ups... But from a real world, practical standpoint, neither of them are great.