Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 27

Thread: Dealing with the insurance company

  1. #1

    Default Dealing with the insurance company

    As some of you may know, I was in an accident on the 29th of last month. I've had a few problems since then, health wise, but right now, I'm more pissed about what the other guy's insurance wants to give me for my car. The accident was his fault, and he was ticketed for it, so it's my opinion that my car should either be repaired or replaced with something of equal value. I know it's nothing special to look at, it's only a '90 Buick Skylark, but I've maintained it regularly and it's a very dependable car. The interior is in good shape, but the paint is really bad, but I don't care about that. I just need to know that I can get in and drive to New York if I wanted to.
    So anyway, the insurance adjuster came out to look at it today, and offered me $500.00 for it. I told him that's not acceptable, and I either want it repaired, or replaced. I've replaced the radiator, tires, alternator, water pump, oil pan gasket and timing chain tensioner, and a whole lot of other things. The car has 132,000 miles on it, but like I said, it runs great. I've got 4 other vehicles that all have gotten well over 200,000 miles, and one was actually double of that.
    So I guess what I want to know is this, is it fair for the insurance company to basically take my car for 500.00 dollars, when to actually buy another one that is in the equivalent condition will cost me twice that, if not more? Because if it wasn't for the other guy's careless driving, I would still be happily driving my Buick.
    Your thoughts?

  2. #2


    I know what you're saying, Ricky! That's the one drawback on keeping a car for years, if it's wrecked you're only going to get the book value (car will be considered totaled) if the cost of repair exceeds that amount. It really sucks when you're in a low income bracket or a fixed income and can't afford to replace the vehicle on what the insurance will give you. I don't think you're in that situation, but it still hurts you in the wallet now because you can't replace the car with anything half decent and running for anywhere near $500. We're in the same boat with a 1989 GMC van and a 1994 Toyota. When the car gets several years on it, you might as well drop collision coverage and put that money in savings to go towards a new purchase down the road. Otherwise, you're just giving the extra money away to the insurance company. Insurance companies and banks are my least favorite corps. to deal with. Unfortunately, they're pretty much a necessity whether we agree with their policies or not. I usually don't agree!

    EDIT: My wife's brother just went through the same gyrations because someone else caused their car to be totaled. He protested to the insurance company and showed receipts for all the things he had recently put in the car. Because he had receipts they upped the amount they'd give him. Maybe you could use that approach if you still have receipts or other proof of what you've put into the car. Just a thought...


  3. #3


    "Fair" is such a peculiar term when dealing with insurance people. When I got my car a bit smushed up by someone else, there was very little damage, but given the age, they still declared it totalled for a not very good price (pretty much the same kind of deal you're getting). They did let us keep the car, so we just pocketed the money, got the front end fixed, and made periodic use of it until we sold it.

    Basically, you'll never get replacement costs from insurance for a vehicle. Injury, pain, and suffering might buy that, but those are intangibles.

  4. #4


    Talk to your insurance agent, and get them involved, that is part of what you pay them for.

  5. #5


    Well this may not solve anything man but what I would do is punch him......... right in the nose. Just pop him.

  6. #6


    He wants to give you 5 hundred and take the car, you tell him NO repair my car to my satisfaction.

    Or replace the car with another car that is the same, get a few estimates on what it will cost to repair the car, the guy that hit you already assumed responseability or he woundn't have come to you.

    It is way cheaper to toss you 500, than to repair the damage, and that is what they are trying to do.

    And if you know someone that owns a body shop, ask him to get involved, the guys I know will fight the insurance co for the coustomer.

    If that don't work look for a lawyer who will help for a peice of the pie, it might cost you 20 to 40%, but it's worth it.

    If I took what the insurance co offered me, at first, I would have nothing today, but I still have a whole pile of there money.

  7. #7


    I'd say go to a professional car fixer place and get an estimate for how much it would cost to get it fixed. Then look around the internet for prices of cars of the same model, make, year and mileage. Then take the documents to your opponent's insurance agent and demand that he pay you at least the lowest amount from the replacement / repair estimates or get you a replacement on his own.
    Unfortunately, the claim of the car being "well maintained" or "could have run another 70k miles" cannot be proven.


  8. #8


    Actually, I can prove the car is well maintained, as I have all the receipts for the maintenance that I've done over the last few years. And I told them that they either replace it with another car of equal value, or repair mine. But they told me it's totaled, and that it's not worth fixing. They claim that if I were to try to sell it in the condition it was in just before the accident, I wouldn't get more than 500.00 for it. But my argument was that I had no intention of selling it, and I don't give a rats ass what it looks like, as long as it's dependable. But they didn't buy that and still insist that the car isn't worth it. When I pressed the adjuster about repairing it, he said that they could possibly get a body from a salvage yard and transfer the parts from mine to it, but even that would cost too much. I said go for it, I want you to do that then, but again, no dice.
    I haven't gotten my insurance company involved yet, but I think I will now. The adjuster for my company just happens to be a friend of mine, so maybe he will have some ideas, but I'm not going to hold my breath.
    I think it's a really shitty thing the way these insurance companies can just tell you "sorry, you will just have to accept what we offer you, or go to hell". After all, I didn't wreck my car, they did. Wouldn't it only be fair to replace it? I'm not asking for a new Rolls Royce here, just a car that's equal to what I had.

  9. #9


    Honestly... see if you can sue the guy for the difference. Insurance companies love to screw people with older cars like that. Do you happen to have documentation of all the repairs/replacements you have made?

    A friend of mine in high school was in a similar situation. Her uncle gave her one of his cars to use to get back and forth... it was an 80's model... but the engine, transmission, and running gear had been recently replaced... so it was in good shape. She got rear-ended and pushed into another car... "sandwiched" as we said... so the car was a total loss. Book value for the vehicle was about $500... so that was all she got out of it. She had to get a lawyer and take the guy that hit her to court to get enough money to buy another car.

    It's not fair in the least... and I don't like it one bit. But that is how it works. That is why I have gap insurance with replacement coverage on my Cobalt. If someone hits me and totals my car the insurance company will give me the option of either paying the car off no matter how much I owe on it, or they will replace my car with another one that is as close in make/model/options/mileage as can be found. It did make my premiums go up a bit... but I think it is worth it for piece of mind.

  10. #10


    Yeah, I'm not happy to say the least about this, but I was just thinking that I'll give them the ultimatum of settling for what I want for the car and something for my time, and pain and suffering, or I'll see them in court. I think they would rather pay out a little more now, than to have to deal with a lawyer and court costs and possibly losing even more, because I've got a good case against them.
    But before I do that, I'm still going to check with my friend, the insurance adjuster for my insurance company. We went to school together, that's how I know him BTW.
    I'll keep you guys posted as to the outcome, good or bad.

Similar Threads

  1. Insurance/etc. for incontinence
    By BabyKat in forum Incontinence
    Replies: 60
    Last Post: 01-Dec-2008, 15:44
  2. dealing with heat
    By uppitycrip in forum Incontinence
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 24-Jul-2008, 15:58
  3. Why is dealing with families so hard?! [Rant]
    By Manigeitora in forum Off-topic
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: 05-Feb-2008, 00:08

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  • - the Adult Baby / Diaper Lover / Incontinence Support Community. is designed to be viewed in Firefox, with a resolution of at least 1280 x 1024.