Results 1 to 8 of 8

Thread: Abena X-Plus Review

  1. #1
    Loopygone

    Default Abena X-Plus Review

    Last nappy review for a while, I won't be trying any more brands after this I don't think, unless I hear of something exceptional for us here in the UK (Cuddlz with prints please :P). The new style Abena X-plus (or L4 if you want to get technical). I've been an abena user ever since I got my first pack of adult disposables, and always the x-plus version (why go with anything less? :P), so this review might be a bit biased :X. But it also means I'm well placed to talk about the little changes that have been made in this version.

    I used to order from Beaucare who aren't the most discreet around, and they're also available from Dorset Nursing Supplies who suffer from a similar problem. Recently through a friend told me about Bambo Nature (thanks Babyalex86 ) who offer very good prices on packs, and free shipping on orders over 50, and crucially they shipped discreetly (well as discreetly as possible for the massive box that turned up :P Big Box o' Nappies Yes, that's a full size bottle of baby powder.)
    So onwards!

    Fit

    I like the fit of these, they're very easy to get right for me after my years of experience with them. The bottom tape being low really helps get a snug fit round the thighs and bum. I know a lot of people have complained about the tapes in the past but for me I haven't had a problem with them for a year or so now, no popping, and no un-sticking. Like I said in my Molicare review, I prefer this placement of bottom tapes. One issue that seems to have gotten worse is the plastic backing, it does seem a little softer which is always good, but also a little thinner. It also stretches very easily, which means no matter how snug you stick them on you'll need to re-tape after an hour or two, they do hold better after this second taping, but it shouldn't be needed. The tapes are again double tapes, so you only get a choice to reposition them once, and again you'll need it once they've stretched out. They do seem to be a little softer, and a little less stiff in the padding now, which is always good, still its best to empty the whole pack and let them expand over time.

    Absorbency

    This is the yard stick that all others are measured in my experience, I doubt there's a nappy out there that can match up to the sheer amount of liquid these can hold with out leaking. 3 heavy beer fuelled wettings are easy peasy, a 4th and it will still contain it, but I wouldn't trust it when sitting down. They swell up as well increasing the already incredible thickness even more. One improvement in this area (yes Improvement!) is the addition of a little more fluff which seems to wick a lot better then I remember, two wettings whilst stood up and it will reach the bum no problem, which increases its soaking power even more. Its still not up there with Molicare which have been the most impressive in this regard, but its more then thick enough to handle anything it can't wick away.

    Look

    I love the look of these, ok they'd be better plain white (or even better covered in teddies ). The way they fit, look and feel seems to be the closest in what I want as an AB, this isn't to take away anything from cuddlz or molicare, but the fit of these seem even more babyish, just a bit puffy outty in all the right places. They do have some writing on them, but I don't mind this over how they used to look, it seems... modern. The wetness indicator is still the same, two stripes of yellow that change colour as you wet. I don't know why they need these through, a wet abena is noticeable from a mile off, the way it swells and the amount of gel that you can see through the plastic. One thing that's always been an issue with abenas is the lack of odour control. They seem to start smelling quicker then other brands when wet, and a wet nappy smell isn't the nicest in the world (well ok cloth nappies do smell great :X). They're also as crinkly as I remember . Cuddlz may be more so in this regard but only because of that landing zone.

    Overall

    I still love these nappies, and they'll always have a special place in my stash. The stretchiness has always been an issue, and it does seem to have gotten worse with these newer ones could be a major problem for bedwetters who move around a lot at night. But the improvement to the tapes, the wicking, and the now softer feel of the plastic and padding all add up and outweigh these concerns. I think the Molicare edges it out slightly, but only because of that stretch issue. However the white is a better look for me then purple.
    One thing that does seem to be an issue with abenas (and probably other brands but I've never used for long enough to be affected) is sometimes you'll get a bad batch, with bad tapes, or leaky plastic. I've never had a problem returning them in the past, and issues do see to be resolved quickly.

    Again with your thoughts :P, I know a lot of people have used these, and there's a lot of opinions about them. I love hearing what you have to say on the subject .

  2. #2

    Default

    Wow. Cheers for another amazing review, Loopy! You've talked me in to buying another batch - it sounds like they've changed quite a bit since I last had some.

    The first lot I had wicked really well and had thick smooth plastic and perfect tapes. Then I got another box a year later with a sort of matte (dimpled) plastic which the tapes didn't stick to very well, and the insides were different - the gel didn't wick like the old ones.

    It's so hard to work out what your favourite nappy is when they keep changing them! I'm sure it's a conspiracy to keep us buying more!

  3. #3
    EmeraldsAndLime

    Default

    Posted this in another thread, but figures this would be a better place (more recent thread).



    Quote Originally Posted by Lukie View Post
    Sitting in one of the new designed X-Plus' right now. Initial impressions were that they aren't too bad, certainly smaller in size than the previous style, though I guess if you like a more discreet, better fitting diaper then this is a good thing. The plastic, unfortunately, feels cheaper and more flimsy which was proven when I taped it up. I like my diapers snug-to-tightly fit and after shifting around a little bit one of the tapes has started to rip the plastic up.

    Despite being thinner, they actually seem to hold the same amount and have survived multiple large wettings. They tend to wick the moisture away fairly well too and in fact I actually feel, for the most part, dry, though it's a bit squishy when I sit in them.

    Generally speaking though, the diaper hasn't changed for the worst overall, my only gripe being the cheaper plastic, but props for a better fitting diaper (for me anyway - the older style didn't fit me quite right, this one is a lot better). Still a high quality diaper in all aspects.

  4. #4

    Default

    How are they size wise? I have historically gotten the medium Abenas, but you say they are smaller now? I wonder if I need to experiment with the large.

  5. #5
    Loopygone

    Default

    I haven't noticed too much of a difference with the large, they're still about the same size as I remeber the old style ones. Maybe an inch or two off the wings, but then the large are pretty big so this wouldn't effect me so much.
    If you're borderline I'd stick with the mediums tbh.



    Quote Originally Posted by tiny View Post
    Wow. Cheers for another amazing review, Loopy! You've talked me in to buying another batch - it sounds like they've changed quite a bit since I last had some.

    The first lot I had wicked really well and had thick smooth plastic and perfect tapes. Then I got another box a year later with a sort of matte (dimpled) plastic which the tapes didn't stick to very well, and the insides were different - the gel didn't wick like the old ones.

    It's so hard to work out what your favourite nappy is when they keep changing them! I'm sure it's a conspiracy to keep us buying more!
    They are different if the last batch you had was that bad, that sounds like a dodgy batch too me, which as I mentioned in the review they do seem to suffer from every now and then. The last load I had would of been around the start of september, they where in the new packaging but old design of the actual nappy. Overall they weren't that different to these one, just a slightly better plastic, and less wicking power.
    I guess I'm more willing to give them the benefit of the doubt because they were my first nappy, and they're still pretty great. The thing is you can't really go wrong with any of the top brands, they're all very good all round, in the end it comes down to personal opinion.
    Last edited by Loopygone; 25-Jan-2010 at 07:44.

  6. #6
    EmeraldsAndLime

    Default

    Yeah, the size difference isn't that great at all. If anything they tend to be a lower-cut and don't rise as high. As Loopy alluded to, it's just a few small reductions off the wings, and the length is slightly reduced as well.

    I'd be confident in saying that if you fit into a medium before, you'll still fit into mediums now... unless you were completely bursting out of them previously, at which point I'd wonder why you were wearing them in the first place.

  7. #7

    Default

    Another fantastic review Loopy & thanks for the mention too

    I havent tried these yet, but these are on my list since Loopy goes on about them soo much ha

  8. #8

    Smile



    Quote Originally Posted by Loopy View Post
    They are different if the last batch you had was that bad, that sounds like a dodgy batch too me...
    I don't think they were dodgy, as such - virtually all nappies seem to come undone or get loose after I've had them on for a short while. (Except maybe Tender ones.) Maybe I wriggle too much.

    It was just such a change the next time I got some. I thought they'd be the same forever.



    Quote Originally Posted by Loopy View Post
    I guess I'm more willing to give them the benefit of the doubt because they were my first nappy, and they're still pretty great.
    I know... my first batch were just... perfect! Sob! :cryhankie:

    They were soooo thick... and comfy... and good wicking... and thick plastic... and strong tapes and.... :cryhankie: WAIL!

    But you're right, they're still amazing.

Similar Threads

  1. abena abriform xplus my review
    By tenabanks in forum Diaper Talk
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: 29-Nov-2009, 22:57
  2. Abena X-Plus
    By RedApple in forum Diaper Talk
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 21-Sep-2009, 23:31
  3. I just put on my first Abena X-Plus
    By Stella in forum Diaper Talk
    Replies: 17
    Last Post: 20-Sep-2009, 11:29
  4. Abena Extra - My review
    By thedlguy in forum Diaper Talk
    Replies: 25
    Last Post: 16-Jul-2009, 14:00

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
ADISC.org - the Adult Baby / Diaper Lover / Incontinence Support Community.
ADISC.org is designed to be viewed in Firefox, with a resolution of at least 1280 x 1024.