I used the Goodnites of the 90's, until they started F-ing with them (shortening, etc). I used a blow dryer to relax the sides, so they wouldn't rip, and at 200+ lbs, amazingly, they worked quite well. I'd NEVER pay $150-$200 for a trip down memory lane. There are too many good alternatives out there, if a person can just not be so persnickety. HDIS has a sample pack for $10 that gives you a chance to try a fair amount, even if you only like one or two styles from the bunch. The rest can be perforated into soakers, and then you can order what you like, BUT, INVARIABLY, someone else will not like what you chose. WTF cares? Buy them! Wear them proudly! You know you need them! Double them up to improve mileage, ripping the wet one off when saturated. Be creative! Find combos of stuff that works, and don't listen to those that rigidly complain about this brand vs that brand. MAKE IT WORK!
Also, if you're bound & determined to keep wearing the current Goodnites, and they're less than satisfactory, use undies, or fixation pants, to provide extra support.